|
Who We Are
Controversial
public policy decisions that affect many people are
unlikely to be accepted unless they are justified, somehow,
by those who make them. Often, this is done by invoking
some form of authority. For example, James
Watt - former US Secretary of the Interior - is
notorious for having invoked the rapture in a Senate
hearing, when he said "I do not know how many future
generations we can count on before the Lord returns"
as a factor to be considered in deciding how much should
be left for future generations. Presumably, this was
also the reason for the
policies for which he was eventually forced out
of office, which include the dismantling of the department,
and the give away of public assets at firesale prices.*
Others invoke science, which is at its best when, like
Galileo, it challenges existing beliefs, and debunks
myths, and, also like Galileo, gets corrected when wrong,
as was his theory of the tides. At its worst, science
provides support for decisions that have already been
made, resting on hubris and on myths that must also
be debunked, such as the delusion also attributed
to Galileo - that given enough resources, it can explain
all things and provide certainty. It is also important
to recognize that science is just one of many ways of
understanding a world in which changes are increasingly
a consequence of human beliefs and behavior. The capacity
to respond to complex problems rests on an understanding
of this changing context, without which scientific explanations
and technical solutions are likely to be irrelevant
no matter how precise.
Clarifying
various forms of uncertainty is critical to managing
public expectations, and to maintaining or re-establishing
public trust in science. It is also expected to better
engage the public, as citizens, in democratic decision-making
processes, in which a major area of uncertainty is whether
their participation will even make any difference in
the final outcome. When science supports high stakes
policy commitments, this kind of broader engagement
is also what makes it possible to detect and correct
errors.
The
Post-Normal Times is dedicated to improving the quality
of public participation in science-based policy decisions
related to the conundrums presented by problems of environmentally
sustainable development, by providing multiple and constructive
perspectives on complex and controversial science and
policy issues. A central focus will be on justifications
provided for controversial high-stakes decisions that
pertain to complex problems such as climate change,
in which the disadvantages of making trade-offs fall
disproportionately on those excluded from the decision-making
process. But we will also cover post-normal aspects
of culture and politics that are the context of science.
We particularly seek out the kinds of information often
missed in formal reports and normal news sources, for
failure to fit into standard categories and established
story lines.
Special themes preliminarily
identified for coverage include:
Demythification of science used to support specific
and selected policy decisions.
"Ignorance of ignorance" i.e.,
blindspots
Uses and abuses of uncertainty in decision-making,
such as the use of science to avoid actually making
a decision
Paradox and contradiction in existing policies
Living in Post-Normal Times- a space for reports
and commentary on the social and cultural context of
science and policy.
This may include
essays, reviews of selected books, movies and artists
that present emerging perspectives, and scenarios of
the future.
* An earlier version of this text was retracted, for
reasons explained here.
Editors, Contributors
and Members of the Advisory Board
Sylvia S. Tognetti,
founder and editor of The Post-Normal Times, is an environmental
science and policy consultant based in Silver Spring,
from where she has a birds eye view of Washington
D.C. She has worked with several international organizations
and has published several reports and articles on subjects
of land, water, and issues of governance related to
the provision of ecosystem services. In the late 1980s/early
1990s, as staff for several scientific committees of
the National Academy of Sciences/National Research Council,
she witnessed first hand the limitations of normal science
as a basis for policy decisions regarding complex and
controversial environmental problems, and the ongoing
conflicts between science and policy. Since then, she
has been in search of a more constructive approach,
and managed to complete an M.A. in geography in 2000,
at the University of Maryland. However, she found that
what is often the most relevant information, never quite
fits into formal science and policy reports. The Post-Normal
Times was created to fill that gap.
For more information.
Angela Guimarães
Pereira, associate-editor of the Post-Normal
Times, studied Environmental Engineering in the New
University of Lisbon in Portugal, Acoustic Studies in
the University of Southampton and earned a PhD in Environmental
Impact Assessment with the same Portuguese university.
In 1996 she started working at the European Commission
Joint Research Centre where she worked to establish
the Knowledge
Assessment Methodologies sector in 1999, and is
responsible for activities on science & society
interfaces, that range from methodologies for knowledge
quality assurance to social research and deployment
of new information technologies for new governance in
Europe. The applications have primarily addressed issues
of sustainability in Europe, including water resources
and climate change, with support from the European Framework
Programmes of research. In 2003, she organized the International
Workshop on Science & Society Interfaces in Milan
Italy, which brought together over 150 professionals
in the field.
Mitra Ardron has
a longstanding interest in the use of communications
technology to bridge information gaps around sustainability
issues, has helped to pioneer non-profit and commercial
uses of the internet, having been a member of teams
that created many of the standards currently in use,
such as http and the url. He also founded GreenNet in
1985 and then co-founded the Association for Progressive
Communications, built the first internet gateway for
AOL, and the first ISP in Russia. He currently works
as an advisor and consultant to companies seeking to
develop and market innovative technologies and ideas
that promote sustainability, and maintains a blog on
sustainability, technology and community at www.mitra.biz/blog.
Paul Baer [bio forthcoming]
Bruna De Marchi
has a background in political science and sociology.
She is now the co-ordinator of the Mass Emergencies
Programme (PEM) at the Institute
of International Sociology in Gorizia (ISIG). She
has lectured extensively and has been a consultant for
many public and private organisations in Europe and
elsewhere. She has been appointed to several committees
and consulting bodies, including the European Commission
Advisory Group on Science and Society for the 6th Research
Framework Programme. Her main research interests are
in the human dimensions of environmental hazards, accidents,
and disasters, particularly risk perception, governance
and communication, the management of uncertainty, and
participatory policy decision processes on health and
safety issues. On such themes, she has been principal
researcher in many international projects. She has considerable
experience in fieldwork and is skilful in a number of
different social science standard and non-standard methods
and techniques. She has great expertise in focus group
work, also in combination with ICT (information and
communication technology).
Mario Giampietro
is the Director of the Unit of Technological Assessment
at the Italian National Institute of Research on Food
and Nutrition (INRAN), and has also been a Visiting
Scholar (1987 -1989; 1993 -1994) and Visiting Professor
(1995) at Cornell University; a Visiting Fellow at Wageningen
University (1997); a Visiting Scientist at the Joint
Research Center of the European Commission of Ispra,
Italy (1998); a Visiting Professor at the Ph.D. Program
of Ecological Economics at the Universitat Autonoma
Barcelona, Spain (1999 2000); Visiting Fellow
at the University of Wisconsin-Madison (in 2002), and
currently, a Visiting Scholar at Penn State University.
He has bachelor degrees in Chemical Engineering and
Biological Sciences, a Masters in Food System Economics,
and a Ph.D. in social sciences obtained from Wageningen
University on the topic of Science for Governance: the
implications of the complexity revolution. He has published
over 100 papers in refereed journals and book chapters
in the fields of Ecological Economics, Energy Analysis,
Sustainable Agriculture, Population and Development,
and Complex Systems Theory applied to the process of
Decision Making in view of Sustainability. In 2003 he
wrote a book published by CRC Press entitled Multi-Scale
Integrated Analysis of Agro-ecosystems. He also
serves on the editorial board of Agriculture Ecosystems
and Environment (Elsevier), Environment, Development
and Sustainability (Kluwer), and the International Journal
of Water (Inderscience). In addition, he is one of the
organizers of the Biennial International Workshop "Advances
in Energy Studies" held since 1996 in Portovenere
(Italy); an elected member of the Management Committee
of the European Society for Ecological Economics (ESEE)
since its establishment in 1996; and the president of
the scientific society liphe4.
Silvio Funtowicz taught
mathematics, logic and research methodology in Buenos
Aires, Argentina. During the decade of 1980 he was a
Research Fellow at the University of Leeds, England.
He is now Head of the Knowledge Assessment Methodologies
Sector, Institute for the Protection and Security of
the Citizen (IPSC), European Commission - Joint Research
Centre (EC-JRC). He is the author of Uncertainty and
Quality in Science for Policy (1990, Kluwer, Dordrecht)
in collaboration with Jerry Ravetz, and numerous papers
in the field of environmental and technological risks
and policy-related research. He is a member of the editorial
board of several publications and of the scientific
committees of many international conferences, and has
lectured extensively.
Gilberto Gallopin
is a Regional Adviser on Environmental Policies, in
the U.N.
Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean
in Santiago, Chile. He is engaged in research and has
contributed numerous publications on topics of ecological
systems analysis, food chain and niche theory, global
modeling, environmental modeling, environmental impact
assessment, environmental and land use prospective,
environment and development nexus, environment and quality
of life, impoverishment and sustainable development,
scenario analysis, policy dialogues, and science and
sustainability.
Jerry Ravetz is
an independent scholar who works on problems of uncertainty
and policy-critical ignorance in contemporary science,
with a focus on quantification, its uses and its abuses.
With S.O. Funtowicz, he developed a notational system,
"NUSAP", for the representation of uncertainty
in quantitative information; and the concept of Post-Normal
Science, a mode of scientific problem-solving
appropriate to policy issues where facts are uncertain,
values in dispute, stakes high and decisions urgent.
He is currently a Visiting Fellow at the James Martin
Institute for Science & Civilization at the Saïd
Business School at Oxford University, England.For more
information.
Laura Ann Schiller
is a straight A student in the 5th grade, plays in a
league champion soccer team, and on the Potomac Trones
basketball team, which has been undefeated for 2 years.
She also sings in a youth choir soon to perform at the
new Strathmore Concert Hall, draws cartoons, is a source
of inspiration to the editor, and a source of perspiration
to her parents.
Jeroen van der Sluijs
graduated at Leiden University in Theoretical Ecology
in 1990. Since 1991 he has been working at the Department
of Science Technology and Society at Utrecht University
on a number of projects related to uncertainties in
climate risk assessment. In 1996 Jeroen participated
in the IIASA Young Scientist Summer Program, working
on uncertainty management in integrated assessment models.
In 1997 he received his Ph.D. for a dissertation entitled
"Anchoring Amid Uncertainty; On the Management
of Uncertainties in Risk Assessment of Anthropogenic
Climate Change". At present Jeroen is associate
professor and co-ordinates the research group "Environmental
Risk Management". Jeroen has been involved in several
international projects on gloabl environmental risks
such as Social
Learning in the Management of Global Environmental Risks
and the european ULYSSES project. He coordinates several
projects on uncertainty management in science for policy
in close collaboration with Dr. Silvio Funtowicz (JRC,
Ispra) and dr. Jerry Ravetz (RMC London) and in projects
around the themes Integrated Assessment, climate change
and stakeholder participation in risk assessment. Recent
projects included the development of a protocol for
uncertainty assessment in emission monitoring for the
RIVM and its application to the emissions of VOC from
paint and a major NUSAP uncertainty assessment of the
B1 scenario as produced with the IMAGE/TIMER energy
model for the IPCC SRES process. For more information.
David Waltner-Toews
is a poet, short story writer, essayist, veterinarian,
and epidemiologist "specializing" in the epidemiology
of zoonoses and food- and water-borne diseases, and
in community-based ecosystem approaches to health. A
full professor in the Department of Population Medicine
at the University of Guelph, he is an author or co-author
of more than 60 peer-reviewed papers, an equal number
of conference presentations, six published books of
poetry and four of nonfiction, including Ecosystem Sustainability
and Health: a Practical Approach (Cambridge, 2004).
As a principle collaborator on research and development
projects in Canada, the Peruvian Amazon, Central America,
Africa and Nepal, he is part of an international network
of scholars working to integrate complex systems theories
with practice to promote sustainable health and development.
He is a member of the Writers Union of Canada,
Pen Canada, The League of Canadian Poets, the College
of Veterinarians of Ontario, the Canadian Public Health
Association, the International Society for Veterinary
Epidemiology and Economics, the Canadian Society for
International Health, the Dirk Gently Gang and founding
president of the Network
for Ecosystem Sustainability and Health. He has
been an advisor to a life partner and two children,
who have occasionally listened to him. For more information.
|